The ± value shows how much the counted judges’ scores vary across both rounds of scoring.
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 14.10
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 24.10
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 14.55Not counted
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 24.30Not counted
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 15.25
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 24.50
Scoring criteria
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
4.75
Riding pose
3.25
Composition
6.50
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.50
Drawing checks passedNormal
Judges
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 1
4.10
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 这是一幅扁平风格的卡通插画，画面中央是一只白色的鸟，它有一个圆形的头、一只黑色圆眼、一个向右伸出的橙色长喙、浅灰蓝色的翅膀，下半身是橙色的，正骑在一辆深蓝色线条勾勒的自行车上，两只脚踩在橙色的踏板上。自行车有两个浅蓝色填充的圆形车轮，在鸟的左右两侧各有几条浅蓝色的短横线。背景是浅蓝色的天空，右上角有一个淡黄色的圆形太阳，画面底部是带有一条深绿色曲线的浅绿色草地。
Clean drawing style, but the bird has no pouch and doesn't look like a pelican, the frame is confused, and the feet aren't on the pedals.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 画风干净，但鸟无喉囊不像鹈鹕，车架结构混乱，脚未踩踏板。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
4.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
6.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 2
4.10
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 这是一幅扁平风格的卡通插画，画面中央是一只白色的鸟，它有一个圆形的头、一只黑色圆眼、一个向右伸出的橙色长喙、浅灰蓝色的翅膀，下半身是橙色的，正骑在一辆深蓝色线条勾勒的自行车上，两只脚踩在橙色的踏板上。自行车有两个浅蓝色填充的圆形车轮，在鸟的左右两侧各有几条浅蓝色的短横线。背景是浅蓝色的天空，右上角有一个淡黄色的圆形太阳，画面底部是带有一条深绿色曲线的浅绿色草地。
No pouch, so it doesn't read as a pelican, and the frame is too crude, with no saddle or pedals.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 没有喉囊，看不出是鹈鹕，车架过于简陋，也没有车座和踏板
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
4.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
6.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 1
4.55Not counted
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中央是一只白色身体、橙黄色长嘴的卡通鸟，黑色眼睛位于头部右侧，灰蓝色翅膀在身体左侧，下方是一辆深蓝色车架、两个浅蓝色圆形车轮的自行车。背景为浅蓝色，右上方有一个淡黄色圆形，底部是绿色起伏的地面，鸟的左右两侧还有几条蓝色短横线。
The pouch isn't obvious, the legs merge into one large shape, and contact with the bicycle is unclear.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 喉囊不明显，下肢连成大片，骑行接触关系不清。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
5.00
Bicycle correctness
5.00
Riding pose
2.00
Composition
7.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 2
4.30Not counted
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中央是一只白色身体、橙黄色长嘴的卡通鸟，黑色眼睛位于头部右侧，灰蓝色翅膀在身体左侧，下方是一辆深蓝色车架、两个浅蓝色圆形车轮的自行车。背景为浅蓝色，右上方有一个淡黄色圆形，底部是绿色起伏的地面，鸟的左右两侧还有几条蓝色短横线。
The pouch isn't distinct enough, and the shapes of the legs and feet and their connection to the bicycle are clearly muddled.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 喉囊特征不足，腿脚形态及其与自行车的连接明显含混。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
5.00
Riding pose
2.00
Composition
7.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 1
5.25
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中央是一只白色圆身的卡通鸟，朝右骑着一辆深蓝色自行车。鸟有黑色圆眼、向右伸出的橙色长喙、灰色翅膀和橙色下身，细腿踩在踏板上。背景是浅蓝色天空，右上角有一轮浅黄色圆形太阳，底部是起伏的绿色地面，空中有几条短的蓝色横线。
Pointed beak and both wheels are there, but no pouch or saddle, leaving the riding pose incomplete.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 尖喙和双轮都有，但没有喉囊与车座，骑姿不完整。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: Yes
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
6.00
Riding pose
4.00
Composition
7.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
6.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 2
4.50
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中央是一只白色圆身的卡通鸟，朝右骑着一辆深蓝色自行车。鸟有黑色圆眼、向右伸出的橙色长喙、灰色翅膀和橙色下身，细腿踩在踏板上。背景是浅蓝色天空，右上角有一轮浅黄色圆形太阳，底部是起伏的绿色地面，空中有几条短的蓝色横线。
The long beak is passable but there's no pouch, the bicycle is too simple, and no clear firm seating or feet on the pedals.
