The ± value shows how much the counted judges’ scores vary across both rounds of scoring.
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 14.85
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 24.05
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 14.30
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 24.05
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 14.90
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 25.00
Scoring criteria
Pelican likeness
4.67
Bicycle correctness
5.17
Riding pose
3.33
Composition
5.67
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.67
Drawing checks passedMonitoring
Judges
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 1
4.85
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 这是一幅扁平风格的插图：一只白色的鸟坐在一辆红色车架的自行车的深棕色车座上。鸟的身体是椭圆形，有一条弯曲的长脖子、圆形的头、一只黑色眼睛和一个大大的橙色喙，背部有灰色的翅膀和尾羽，两条细细的橙色腿向下伸到车架中部的曲柄和踏板处。自行车有两个黑色轮子，带灰色辐条，前部有黑色车把；背景是由浅到深渐变的蓝色天空，左上角有一朵白云，下方是一块椭圆形的绿色草地。
Beak is short with no clear pouch, so it doesn't look like a pelican; the whole bicycle floats above the grass, and the wings aren't holding the handlebars either.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 喙短且没有明显喉囊，不像鹈鹕；整车悬浮在草地上方，翅膀也没握车把。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: Yes
Feet on the pedals: Yes
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
6.00
Riding pose
5.00
Composition
5.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 2
4.05
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 这是一幅扁平风格的插图：一只白色的鸟坐在一辆红色车架的自行车的深棕色车座上。鸟的身体是椭圆形，有一条弯曲的长脖子、圆形的头、一只黑色眼睛和一个大大的橙色喙，背部有灰色的翅膀和尾羽，两条细细的橙色腿向下伸到车架中部的曲柄和踏板处。自行车有两个黑色轮子，带灰色辐条，前部有黑色车把；背景是由浅到深渐变的蓝色天空，左上角有一朵白云，下方是一块椭圆形的绿色草地。
Beak is too short to look like a pelican; legs are detached from the body, the frame is odd, and the whole bicycle floats in the air.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 喙太短，不像鹈鹕；腿和身体分离，车架怪异，整车悬空。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: Yes
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
5.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
5.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 1
4.30
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中央是一只白色、灰色轮廓的鸟，长颈向右上方伸出，头部有黑色眼睛和橙黄色长嘴，身体下方是一辆红色车架、黑色轮胎和灰色辐条的自行车。背景为浅蓝色，左上方有一朵白云，底部是一块横向展开的绿色椭圆形地面。
Bird's feet aren't on the pedals, handlebars float in the air, and the frame connections clearly don't make sense.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 鸟脚未踩踏板，车把悬空，车架连接明显不合理。
Long beak and throat pouch: Yes
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: Yes
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
6.00
Bicycle correctness
4.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
5.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 2
4.05
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中央是一只白色、灰色轮廓的鸟，长颈向右上方伸出，头部有黑色眼睛和橙黄色长嘴，身体下方是一辆红色车架、黑色轮胎和灰色辐条的自行车。背景为浅蓝色，左上方有一朵白云，底部是一块横向展开的绿色椭圆形地面。
Handlebars float in the air, legs are detached from the body, and there isn't enough contact to make the riding pose work.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 车把悬空，腿部与身体脱节，骑行接触关系不足。
Long beak and throat pouch: Yes
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: Yes
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
5.00
Bicycle correctness
4.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
5.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 1
4.90
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 浅蓝色天空中，左上方有一朵白色云。画面中央偏上，一只白色卡通鸟面向右侧，橙色长喙、黑色眼睛、灰色翅膀和尾羽，坐在棕色车座上。红色车架的自行车有黑色车把、两个带灰色辐条的黑色车轮，以及橙黄色踏板，位于下方一块绿色椭圆形地面之上。
Bird is perched on the saddle, but has no legs and isn't holding the handlebars, and doesn't look like a typical pelican.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 鸟停在车座上，但没有腿和握把，也不像典型鹈鹕。
Long beak and throat pouch: Yes
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: Yes
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
6.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
7.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
5.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 2
5.00
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 浅蓝色天空中，左上方有一朵白色云。画面中央偏上，一只白色卡通鸟面向右侧，橙色长喙、黑色眼睛、灰色翅膀和尾羽，坐在棕色车座上。红色车架的自行车有黑色车把、两个带灰色辐条的黑色车轮，以及橙黄色踏板，位于下方一块绿色椭圆形地面之上。
Saddle and handlebars are visible, but the bird's legs don't connect with the pedals and its wings aren't holding the handlebars.
