The ± value shows how much the counted judges’ scores vary across both rounds of scoring.
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 13.60
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 24.40
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 14.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 24.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 13.60
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 23.90
Scoring criteria
Pelican likeness
3.83
Bicycle correctness
4.83
Riding pose
2.00
Composition
5.67
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.33
Drawing checks passedMonitoring
Judges
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 1
3.60
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 这是一张扁平风格的插画：一只白色的鸟站在一辆红色车架的自行车上方。鸟的身体呈椭圆形，脖子长，头是圆的，有一只黑色眼睛和橙色的尖喙，两条细长的橙色腿伸向下方的黑色车座。自行车有两个黑色大车轮和一个深色的牙盘，停在占画面下部约三分之一的绿色草地上；上方是由浅到深渐变的蓝色天空，右上角有一个带放射状光线的黄色太阳。
Bird floats above the saddle, its feet aren't on the pedals, and its beak is too short to look like a pelican.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 鸟悬浮在车座上方，脚没踩踏板，喙太短，不像鹈鹕。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
3.00
Bicycle correctness
5.00
Riding pose
2.00
Composition
5.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.00
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 2
4.40
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 这是一张扁平风格的插画：一只白色的鸟站在一辆红色车架的自行车上方。鸟的身体呈椭圆形，脖子长，头是圆的，有一只黑色眼睛和橙色的尖喙，两条细长的橙色腿伸向下方的黑色车座。自行车有两个黑色大车轮和一个深色的牙盘，停在占画面下部约三分之一的绿色草地上；上方是由浅到深渐变的蓝色天空，右上角有一个带放射状光线的黄色太阳。
Bird floats above the saddle, its feet aren't on the pedals, and its short beak makes it look not much like a pelican.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 鸟悬浮在车座上方，脚没踩踏板，喙短，不太像鹈鹕。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
6.00
Riding pose
2.00
Composition
6.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 1
4.00
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中一只白色、灰色轮廓的长颈鸟位于红色自行车上方，鸟嘴细长呈橙黄色，黑色眼睛在头部右侧，两条橙色腿向下弯曲。自行车有两个黑色圆形车轮、红色车架和黑色车座，下方是绿色地面，背景是浅蓝色天空。右上方有一个黄色圆形太阳，周围分布着黄色短线状光芒。
Original (Chinese) 鸟悬在车座上方，脚未踩踏板，传动结构脱节。
Long beak and throat pouch: Yes
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
5.00
Bicycle correctness
4.00
Riding pose
2.00
Composition
6.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 2
4.00
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中一只白色、灰色轮廓的长颈鸟位于红色自行车上方，鸟嘴细长呈橙黄色，黑色眼睛在头部右侧，两条橙色腿向下弯曲。自行车有两个黑色圆形车轮、红色车架和黑色车座，下方是绿色地面，背景是浅蓝色天空。右上方有一个黄色圆形太阳，周围分布着黄色短线状光芒。
Original (Chinese) 鸟悬在车座上方，腿未接触踏板，骑行关系不成立。
Long beak and throat pouch: Yes
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
5.00
Bicycle correctness
4.00
Riding pose
2.00
Composition
6.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 1
3.60
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面上半部是浅蓝色天空，右上角有一轮带短射线的黄色太阳；下半部是绿色地面，中间有一道较深的绿色弧形。画面中央偏右，一只白身、橙喙、橙腿、黑眼的鸟骑在一辆红色自行车上，车头朝右。自行车有两个黑色轮圈、黑色座垫和黑色车把，车架中部下方有一个带十字的黑色小圆。
No pouch, the bird's body hangs in the air, and its feet aren't on the pedals.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 无喉囊且鸟身悬空，脚未踩踏板。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
3.00
Bicycle correctness
5.00
Riding pose
2.00
Composition
5.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 2
3.90
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面上半部是浅蓝色天空，右上角有一轮带短射线的黄色太阳；下半部是绿色地面，中间有一道较深的绿色弧形。画面中央偏右，一只白身、橙喙、橙腿、黑眼的鸟骑在一辆红色自行车上，车头朝右。自行车有两个黑色轮圈、黑色座垫和黑色车把，车架中部下方有一个带十字的黑色小圆。
White bird hangs above an empty saddle, with no pouch and neither foot on the pedals.
