The ± value shows how much the counted judges’ scores vary across both rounds of scoring.
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 14.60
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 23.80
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 14.60Not counted
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 25.65Not counted
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 13.75
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 23.90
Scoring criteria
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
4.25
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
5.25
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.75
Drawing checks passedNormal
Judges
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 1
4.60
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 这是一幅浅蓝色背景上的扁平风格插画，画面中央是一只白色的鸟，鸟的身体呈椭圆形，翅膀为浅灰色，眼睛是一个黑色圆点，朝右伸出一个很大的橙色尖喙，所有轮廓都用深蓝色粗线勾勒。鸟坐在一辆自行车上方，自行车由两个深蓝色圆形车轮和一个红色三角形车架组成，车架中下部有一个带曲柄的小圆形链盘，鸟的深色细腿连到曲柄上，翅膀上方也有一根深色线条斜向伸出。一条浅蓝色波浪线横穿画面下部，从两个车轮的下半部分穿过，鸟头部上方左侧还有几道灰色短弧线。
Frame and handlebars are muddled, wings overlap the handlebars out of place, and the bird doesn't look much like a pelican.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 车架和车把结构混乱，翅膀与车把错位重叠，鸟不太像鹈鹕。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: Yes
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
5.00
Riding pose
5.00
Composition
5.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 2
3.80
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 这是一幅浅蓝色背景上的扁平风格插画，画面中央是一只白色的鸟，鸟的身体呈椭圆形，翅膀为浅灰色，眼睛是一个黑色圆点，朝右伸出一个很大的橙色尖喙，所有轮廓都用深蓝色粗线勾勒。鸟坐在一辆自行车上方，自行车由两个深蓝色圆形车轮和一个红色三角形车架组成，车架中下部有一个带曲柄的小圆形链盘，鸟的深色细腿连到曲柄上，翅膀上方也有一根深色线条斜向伸出。一条浅蓝色波浪线横穿画面下部，从两个车轮的下半部分穿过，鸟头部上方左侧还有几道灰色短弧线。
Frame is too crude, no handlebars or saddle, messy leg lines, and the ground line runs through the wheels.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 车架过于简陋，没有车把和车座，腿线凌乱，地面线穿过车轮。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
4.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
5.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 1
4.60Not counted
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 浅蓝色背景中，一只米白色、深蓝灰色轮廓的鸟位于画面中央，朝向右侧，长嘴呈橙黄色，翅膀带有浅灰蓝色块。鸟的下方是一辆红色三角形车架的自行车，两个深蓝灰色圆形车轮左右排列，鸟的腿伸向车架和踏板附近。画面底部有一条浅蓝色弧线横向穿过两个车轮后方。
Original (Chinese) 鸟与车架叠接含混，缺少明确车座、车把及踩踏关系。
Long beak and throat pouch: Yes
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
6.00
Bicycle correctness
4.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
6.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 2
5.65Not counted
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 浅蓝色背景中，一只米白色、深蓝灰色轮廓的鸟位于画面中央，朝向右侧，长嘴呈橙黄色，翅膀带有浅灰蓝色块。鸟的下方是一辆红色三角形车架的自行车，两个深蓝灰色圆形车轮左右排列，鸟的腿伸向车架和踏板附近。画面底部有一条浅蓝色弧线横向穿过两个车轮后方。
Original (Chinese) 长喙喉囊清楚，但肢体与车架交错，踏板接触不明确。
Long beak and throat pouch: Yes
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
8.00
Bicycle correctness
5.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
7.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
5.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 1
3.75
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 浅蓝色背景上，一只白色鸟侧身朝右，圆头、小黑眼、长橙色喙，身体带浅灰块面和深色轮廓。鸟坐在红色三角车架的自行车上，车架位于画面中下部，前后各有一个深色圆轮，轮下有一条浅蓝横线。
Two wheels and a pointed beak, but no pouch, and the bird's body floats above the saddle instead of sitting on it.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 有双轮和尖喙，但无喉囊，鸟身悬空未坐车座。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
4.00
Riding pose
2.00
Composition
5.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 2
3.90
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 浅蓝色背景上，一只白色鸟侧身朝右，圆头、小黑眼、长橙色喙，身体带浅灰块面和深色轮廓。鸟坐在红色三角车架的自行车上，车架位于画面中下部，前后各有一个深色圆轮，轮下有一条浅蓝横线。
Wheels and frame are there, but no pouch or saddle, feet off the pedals, and loose connections between wheels and frame.
