The ± value shows how much the counted judges’ scores vary across both rounds of scoring.
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 13.50
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 24.70
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 14.90Not counted
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 25.10Not counted
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 15.15
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 26.35
Scoring criteria
Pelican likeness
3.75
Bicycle correctness
6.75
Riding pose
4.00
Composition
6.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
Drawing checks passedNormal
Judges
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 1
3.50
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 这是一幅扁平风格的插画，画面中央有一只灰白色的鸟坐在一辆蓝色自行车上。鸟有圆形的头和一只黑色眼睛，头顶有两个圆环状的凸起，灰蓝色的翅膀向两侧张开，橙色的细长双腿向下踩在踏板附近，橙色的喙朝向左侧。自行车有两个白色的轮子，轮子上有辐条，中间的链轮是黄色的；背景是浅蓝色渐变，上方有白色的云朵轮廓，自行车两侧有几条蓝色短横线，地面上有一片椭圆形的浅色阴影。
The bird's shape is muddled, its beak is hidden and points backward, and it's completely unrecognizable as a pelican.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 鸟的造型混乱，喙被遮挡还朝后，完全认不出是鹈鹕。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: Yes
Pelican likeness
2.00
Bicycle correctness
6.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
4.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
2.00
Claude Opus 5.5 · medium · Pass 2
4.70
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 这是一幅扁平风格的插画，画面中央有一只灰白色的鸟坐在一辆蓝色自行车上。鸟有圆形的头和一只黑色眼睛，头顶有两个圆环状的凸起，灰蓝色的翅膀向两侧张开，橙色的细长双腿向下踩在踏板附近，橙色的喙朝向左侧。自行车有两个白色的轮子，轮子上有辐条，中间的链轮是黄色的；背景是浅蓝色渐变，上方有白色的云朵轮廓，自行车两侧有几条蓝色短横线，地面上有一片椭圆形的浅色阴影。
The bike is drawn well, but the wings hide the beak and look messy, so the bird isn't recognizable as a pelican.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 自行车画得不错，但喙被翅膀遮住，翅膀杂乱，认不出是鹈鹕。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: Yes
Feet on the pedals: Yes
Pelican likeness
3.00
Bicycle correctness
7.00
Riding pose
5.00
Composition
5.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
3.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 1
4.90Not counted
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中央是一只骑着蓝绿色自行车的卡通鸟，身体呈浅灰蓝色，头顶有两个圆形凸起，翅膀和尾羽向两侧展开，橙色的双腿伸向脚踏板。自行车有两个深蓝色轮圈、浅色辐条的大圆轮，鸟身左后方露出一块带橙色条纹的黄色形状。背景为浅蓝色，上方有白色波浪线，两侧有蓝绿色短横线，车轮下方有灰蓝色椭圆阴影。
Original (Chinese) 头喙结构难以辨认，羽翼重叠且踏板连接混乱。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: Yes
Feet on the pedals: Yes
Pelican likeness
3.00
Bicycle correctness
6.00
Riding pose
5.00
Composition
7.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
GPT-6 Astra · medium · Pass 2
5.10Not counted
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中央是一只骑着蓝绿色自行车的卡通鸟，身体呈浅灰蓝色，头顶有两个圆形凸起，翅膀和尾羽向两侧展开，橙色的双腿伸向脚踏板。自行车有两个深蓝色轮圈、浅色辐条的大圆轮，鸟身左后方露出一块带橙色条纹的黄色形状。背景为浅蓝色，上方有白色波浪线，两侧有蓝绿色短横线，车轮下方有灰蓝色椭圆阴影。
Original (Chinese) 头部形态异常，车座偏离身体，踏板连接不清。
Long beak and throat pouch: Yes
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: No
Feet on the pedals: Yes
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
6.00
Riding pose
4.00
Composition
8.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
4.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 1
5.15
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中央是一只白色卡通鸟骑在一辆蓝色自行车上。鸟的身体呈圆形，戴着浅蓝色镜片的圆框眼镜，橙色的喙衔着一只橙色信封，灰蓝色翅膀向两侧张开，两条橙色的腿踩在踏板上。自行车有两个带辐条的白色车轮和黄色轮毂，背景是浅蓝色，上方有白色波浪形云朵，车轮旁有几条短横线，车下有浅灰色阴影。
Flat beak with no pouch, both wings spread and one foot hanging in the air, so it doesn't look like it's riding.
Machine translated
Original (Chinese) 扁喙无喉囊，双翼张开且一脚悬空，不像在骑车。
Long beak and throat pouch: No
Two wheels: Yes
Frame connects the wheels: Yes
Bird sits on the seat: Yes
Feet on the pedals: No
Pelican likeness
4.00
Bicycle correctness
7.00
Riding pose
3.00
Composition
7.00
Obvious errors (higher is better)
5.00
Grok 4.7 · medium · Pass 2
6.35
What the judge sees: Original (Chinese) 画面中央是一只白色卡通鸟骑在一辆蓝色自行车上。鸟的身体呈圆形，戴着浅蓝色镜片的圆框眼镜，橙色的喙衔着一只橙色信封，灰蓝色翅膀向两侧张开，两条橙色的腿踩在踏板上。自行车有两个带辐条的白色车轮和黄色轮毂，背景是浅蓝色，上方有白色波浪形云朵，车轮旁有几条短横线，车下有浅灰色阴影。
A cartoon pelican sits on the bike, but one foot is off the pedals and the handlebars are unclear too.
